Latest revision |
Your text |
Line 8: |
Line 8: |
| | | |
| == Image Quality Templates == | | == Image Quality Templates == |
− | I am starting this discussion to gather opinions on whether or not the {<nowiki/>{[[Template:File-quality|Image-quality]]}} template should be split into separate templates like [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Image_quality_templates Wikipedia] does. These separate templates would specify what exactly the problem is with a particular image, along with how to go about fixing it. Examples of what I mean can be seen [[User:AlexBot2004/Sandbox 3|here]]. Please comment leaving your opinion and vote {{Support}} or {{Oppose}} below. '''~''' [[User:AlexBot2004|<span style="color:#1C662A">'''AlexBot2004'''</span>]] ([[User talk:AlexBot2004|<span style="color:black">Talk</span>]]) 22:23, May 17, 2020 (EDT) | + | I am starting this discussion to gather opinions on whether or not the {{t|Image-quality}} template should be split into separate templates like [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Image_quality_templates Wikipedia] does. These separate templates would specify what exactly the problem is with a particular image, along with how to go about fixing it. Examples of what I mean can be seen [[User:AlexBot2004/Sandbox 3|here]]. Please comment leaving your opinion and vote {{Support}} or {{Oppose}} below. '''~''' [[User:AlexBot2004|<span style="color:#1C662A">'''AlexBot2004'''</span>]] ([[User talk:AlexBot2004|<span style="color:black">Talk</span>]]) 22:23, May 17, 2020 (EDT) |
| | | |
− | {{Voting||regular|determine whether or not the {<nowiki/>{[[Template:File-quality|Image-quality]]}<nowiki/>} template should be split into separate templates}} | + | {{Voting||regular|determine whether or not the {{t|Image-quality}} template should be split into separate templates}} |
| | | |
− | ===Support=== | + | ===Comments=== |
− | :There are more than one ways for images to be improved, and while {<nowiki/>{[[Template:File-quality|Image-quality]]}} can accept a parameter detailing what should be done to the image (removing transparency, changing to a PNG, and so on), it would be better to have a template that can tell the reader what's the issue with the image. While [[Special:Diff/259249|Trig Jegman]]'s objection is understandable that it may be more difficult navigating categories, the trade-off would be worthwhile as editors targeting a certain category may focus on that category. While there are not many templates that I could imagine, [[Special:PermanentLink/259247|what OP has provided]] seems to be concise and can fit what we have in [[:Category:Files needing improvement|Category:Low quality images]]: lossy compression in [[:File:House of Phoebe NL.jpeg]], bad screenshot in [[:File:Isabelle-letter.jpg]], and low-resolution in [[:File:Blanca April Fools.png]]. [[File:Acnl spr four-leafed clover.png|x24px|link=User:Decomposer]][[User talk:Decomposer|{{colorshow|006600|Decomposer}}]] 23:49, May 17, 2020 (EDT) | + | : {{comment}} [[File:Sunmarshsignature.png|link=User:Sunmarsh]] '''<small><span style="font-variant:small-caps">([[User_talk:Sunmarsh|<span style="color:#7B7B7B">talk</span>]])</span></small>''' 22:55, May 17, 2020 (EDT) |
| + | :I think that it's important to provide different specifications for change, but I think that the templates should use the {{t|Notice Box}} format to be consistent with other site notices. Maybe a general image notice box can be created, and then depending on the parameters input it will generate different text/instructions. If the instructions are all markedly different or long then perhaps it is then worth it to start differentiating the templates, but I would still make use of {{t|Notice Box}}. |
| | | |
| ===Oppose=== | | ===Oppose=== |
Line 19: |
Line 20: |
| :I don't see a need to further split image quality any more than it already is. [[Nookipedia:Image Requests]] is not that full--relatively speaking--especially compared to other same size wikis that rely on only 1 organization for low quality images. To further split into categories simply makes it more difficult to find images to replace. Image quality is as straight-forward as it gets. An image is of low quality and needs improvement. No one is going to have their doubts about why [[:File:DKJ.jpg]] is of a low quality, and this likely applies to most other images. If there is a possibility of doubt or even as a fail same, Image-quality can use the reason parameter to describe in much more specific detail as to WHY an image needs recapture or reuploaded than multiple categories can. | | :I don't see a need to further split image quality any more than it already is. [[Nookipedia:Image Requests]] is not that full--relatively speaking--especially compared to other same size wikis that rely on only 1 organization for low quality images. To further split into categories simply makes it more difficult to find images to replace. Image quality is as straight-forward as it gets. An image is of low quality and needs improvement. No one is going to have their doubts about why [[:File:DKJ.jpg]] is of a low quality, and this likely applies to most other images. If there is a possibility of doubt or even as a fail same, Image-quality can use the reason parameter to describe in much more specific detail as to WHY an image needs recapture or reuploaded than multiple categories can. |
| | | |
− | ===Comments===
| + | [[Category:Active Discussions]] |
− | : {{comment}} [[File:Sunmarshsignature.png|link=User:Sunmarsh]] '''<small><span style="font-variant:small-caps">([[User_talk:Sunmarsh|<span style="color:#7B7B7B">talk</span>]])</span></small>''' 22:55, May 17, 2020 (EDT)
| |
− | :I think that it's important to provide different specifications for change, but I think that the templates should use the {{t|Notice Box}} format to be consistent with other site notices. Maybe a general image notice box can be created, and then depending on the parameters input it will generate different text/instructions. If the instructions are all markedly different or long then perhaps it is then worth it to start differentiating the templates, but I would still make use of {{t|Notice Box}}.
| |
− | :Regarding difficulty in navigating the categories, all images that are included in the subcategories can also be included in the parent category [[:Category:Files needing improvement|Category:Low quality images]] for those who want to look at the images that need help at a glance, but giving the option for editors to focus on a particular subcategory if they wanted to. [[File:Acnl spr four-leafed clover.png|x24px|link=User:Decomposer]][[User talk:Decomposer|{{colorshow|006600|Decomposer}}]] 23:49, May 17, 2020 (EDT)
| |
− | | |
− | == New leader? ==
| |
− | | |
− | From the looks of it, {{u|LoneShadowStar}} has completely left the site. As such, do you think a replacement for Project Images would be necessary? -- [[User:PanchamBro|PanchamBro]] ([[User talk:PanchamBro|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/PanchamBro|contributions]]) 03:01, June 9, 2022 (EDT)
| |
− | :Yep - given Lone hasn't edited for over two years, I've gone ahead and opened the project for a new leader, if anyone experienced is interested. '''~[[User:SuperHamster|''<span style="color:#07517C;">Super</span>''<span style="color:#6FA23B;">Hamster</span>]]''' <small>[[User talk:SuperHamster|Talk]] [[Special:Contribs/SuperHamster|Contribs]]</small> 03:34, June 9, 2022 (EDT)
| |
− | | |
− | == Leader ==
| |
− | {{Archive top|result={{u|Kalina70}} is the new leader of Project Images per voting results. [[User:HylianAngel|HylianAngel]] ([[User talk:HylianAngel|talk]]) 03:45, June 27, 2022 (EDT)}}
| |
− | I would like to help in this project and be a leader. I also plans to improve this project, such as: updating the project page, uploading requested/better quality photos, categorizing images, creating new categories for images and renaming images (If it is necessary). {{User:Kalina70/Sig}} 11:12, June 17, 2022 (CET)
| |
− | :{{Support}} I think you would be a great leader for handling this project, since you've done a lot of good work with [[Nookipedia:Project Clean-Up|Project Clean-Up]], which involves similar work. [[User:HylianAngel|HylianAngel]] ([[User talk:HylianAngel|talk]]) 03:54, June 18, 2022 (EDT)
| |
− | :{{Support}}, per HylianAngel above. --<span class="jake-signature">[[User:Jake|<span class="jake-signature-name" style="font-family:Coustard,Verdana; color:#f73422; text-shadow: #e0e0e0 1px 1px 0;">Jake</span>]] [[User_talk:Jake|<span class="jake-signature-talk" style="font-family:Coustard,Verdana; color:#f75b22; text-shadow: #e0e0e0 1px 1px 0;">(talk)</span>]]</span> 16:49, June 18, 2022 (EDT)
| |
− | :{{Support}} per HylianAngel. -- [[User:PanchamBro|PanchamBro]] ([[User talk:PanchamBro|talk]] • [[Special:Contributions/PanchamBro|contributions]]) 17:21, June 18, 2022 (EDT)
| |
− | {{Archive bottom}}
| |
− | | |
− | == "Gameplay Screenshots of..." categories ==
| |
− | | |
− | The project page (''Purpose & Guidelines'' section) mentions a few categories starting with "Gameplay screenshots of...":
| |
− | <pre>Then, give it the additional category "Gameplay Screenshots of Villagers" or "Gameplay Screenshots of Special Characters", depending on the character.</pre>
| |
− | However those categories were deleted. Are there any NH equivalents to the villager/special character categories? (I tried to find them in [[Help:Categories]] but to no success.)
| |
− | | |
− | In any case this section should probably be updated. [[File:Sit_Down_NH_Reaction_Icon.png|30px]] {{User:Xena/sig}} 18:27, September 27, 2023 (EDT)
| |
− | :The page is severely outdated, so I would disregard it for now. I went ahead and fixed some of the category names on the project page just now though. There are similar categories at [[:Category:New Horizons villager screenshots]] and [[:Category:New Horizons event screenshots]], you can see the family of sub-categories at [[:Category:New Horizons screenshots]]. [[User:HylianAngel|HylianAngel]] ([[User talk:HylianAngel|talk]]) 19:26, September 27, 2023 (EDT)
| |
− | | |
− | ::Thank you! ^^ Hopefully this helps a few newcomers that were just as confused. {{User:Xena/sig}} 17:22, September 28, 2023 (EDT)
| |