Talk:Super Smash Bros. Melee
Do we really need coverage on this game? The game has little-to-no Animal Crossing elements. In fact, the trophies are the only thing that's Animal Crossing related. I don't think we need to cover this game just because of a few trophy information. 
MarioTalk to-a me! 20:33, September 12, 2013 (EDT)
- I completely disagree, we cover everything on the subject of Animal Crossing, providing the information is canon. Even if the game has little reference to the series then we'll still cover. In fact, the majority of the NIWA wikis have articles for the Super Brothers series as long as the content that the wiki covers makes an appearance in the game. So my stance on this is that coverage of this game is completely necessary.--XXSuperXXNintendoXx (talk) 21:51, September 12, 2013 (EDT)
- Okay. So, what extent should we cover this information? After all, I'm still a relatively new user and the wiki doesn't really have any sort of coverage policies, so my best bet is to ask somebody who's spent more time here. And, is there an established canon for Animal Crossing? Super Smash Bros. games don't seem very "canon-y" to me when it comes to Animal Crossing. Now, I'm not saying that we shouldn't cover Super Smash Bros., but the "providing the information is canon" part confuses me.
MarioAs for starters, we apparently don't cover the playable characters including-a me. 00:07, September 14, 2013 (EDT)
- Okay. So, what extent should we cover this information? After all, I'm still a relatively new user and the wiki doesn't really have any sort of coverage policies, so my best bet is to ask somebody who's spent more time here. And, is there an established canon for Animal Crossing? Super Smash Bros. games don't seem very "canon-y" to me when it comes to Animal Crossing. Now, I'm not saying that we shouldn't cover Super Smash Bros., but the "providing the information is canon" part confuses me.
Irrelevant Information[edit]
Given that this title's only Animal Crossing content is the trophies, there's no reason to include the entire character roster here. The only information relevant to this wiki is the trophies and pointing out how the game predates the global Gamecube releases and thus has some quirks from its localization process. I'd argue all the Smash Bros. pages should be like this because if people wanted detailed Smash content, they'd be going to a wiki that covers Smash Bros, not Animal Crossing. If there's no argument, I can go about doing this ASAP. Rebochan (talk) 14:33, April 30, 2020 (EDT)
- I'd say the point of having the character rooster on this wiki is because we're NIWA affiliates, thus we're linking back to other wikis in the network. Paviinka
(Message me!) 16:14, April 30, 2020 (EDT)
